Gardening as Exercise and How Much It Really Counts
A neighbour of mine cancelled her gym membership in March on the grounds that she had just taken on an allotment plot and would be getting plenty of exercise without paying for it.

A neighbour of mine cancelled her gym membership in March on the grounds that she had just taken on an allotment plot and would be getting plenty of exercise without paying for it. By July the plot looked genuinely good, her right shoulder ached every evening, and her resting heart rate had not moved a single beat. She asked me, half joking, whether her own garden had conned her.
Not quite. Three seasons of digging beds and shifting compost is real physical work, and the measurements on garden jobs are more flattering than most people assume. The trouble is that it is a different shape of work from the thing she stopped doing, and that difference explains both the sore shoulder and the unchanged pulse. I spent one autumn wearing a chest strap through ordinary garden jobs, partly out of curiosity and partly because I wanted to stop guessing when people asked me this.
What an hour in the garden actually costs you
Physiologists compare activities using the MET, which is simply a multiple of what your body burns while sitting still. Walking briskly on flat ground sits at about 4.3. The published compendium of activities lists garden jobs across a wide spread, and that spread is the entire point.
| Garden job | METs | Comparable to |
|---|---|---|
| Watering with a hose or can | 1.5 | Standing at a kitchen counter |
| Sowing seeds, potting on | 2.3 | Slow indoor walking |
| Weeding and hand cultivating | 3.5 | An easy stroll |
| Raking leaves | 3.8 | Walking at normal pace |
| Digging or turning a bed | 5.0 | Cycling at 16 km an hour |
| Pushing a manual mower | 6.0 | Jogging slowly |
| Shifting compost by barrow | 6.3 | Climbing stairs steadily |
Run the arithmetic for a person of 78 kilograms. Forty five minutes of turning a bed at 5.0 METs works out at roughly 275 kilocalories, which is a little more than a 45 minute swim at an easy pace. Forty five minutes of watering comes to about 80, most of which you would have burned anyway. The same hour outdoors can be a workout or a hobby, and the only variable is which job you chose.
My own strap data said something similar in a blunter way. A heavy afternoon of barrow work and double digging put me at an average of 118 beats per minute across 90 minutes. An afternoon of sowing trays and labelling them averaged 79, which is roughly what I get watching television with a cup of tea in my hand.
The claim that gardening counts as moderate activity is only half right
Health guidance in both the UK and the United States lists gardening as an example of moderate activity that can go towards the weekly 150 minute target. I have repeated that line myself for years and I now think it quietly misleads people, my neighbour included.
The energy figures support it. The heart rate trace does not. In a 70 minute weeding session I logged 11 minutes above 120 beats per minute. The rest was spent crouched, sorting, deciding whether something was a seedling or a weed, and walking to the water butt. A plain 30 minute walk in the same week gave me 26 minutes above that threshold. The walk was less than half the duration and delivered more than twice the sustained effort.
So gardening reliably gives you three things: time on your feet instead of in a chair, loaded movement that asks something of your legs and grip, and daylight. It unreliably gives you cardiovascular training, because the activity stops every ninety seconds and that is the nature of the work. Nobody digs for 40 minutes without standing up to look at what they have done.
If your goal is a lower resting heart rate, the garden will not get you there on its own. If your goal is to stop sitting for eleven hours a day and to keep carrying your own shopping at seventy, it is one of the better things you can do with a Saturday. Those are different goals and the advice collapses them into one.
The jobs that leave you sore and the ones that injure you
Here is the part the public health framing leaves out entirely. Garden work is loaded, repetitive, one sided and often done at a bad angle, which is close to a textbook recipe for a soft tissue strain.
A full ten litre watering can weighs ten kilograms. Carrying one in your right hand across a plot forty times in an evening is forty repetitions of an asymmetric load, and your spine pays for the asymmetry rather than your arm. Two cans, one in each hand, is heavier in total and much kinder to you.
Bending from the waist to weed is the other common one. Forty minutes of that puts a sustained load on the lower back with no movement to relieve it. Kneeling on a pad, or sitting on an upturned crate, changes the job completely. I learned this expensively. In February two years ago I moved thirty sacks of leaf mould from a car boot to the far corner of the garden in one afternoon, felt fine that evening, and then could not put my own socks on for nine days.
Overhead pruning is the shoulder one, and it is what caught my neighbour. Secateurs or loppers held above shoulder height for long stretches loads the rotator cuff in a position it does not like. Twenty minutes is usually fine. Two hours of hedge work in one go is how people in their fifties discover they have a shoulder.
How to make a weekend session actually count
None of this needs a plan or a tracker. Four small changes shifted my own sessions from pleasant to genuinely useful, and they cost nothing.
Start with one continuous job and hold it for twenty five minutes before you let yourself wander off to look at the beans. Continuity is the whole difference between 11 minutes of effort and 26. I set a timer on my phone because otherwise I drift, every time.
Put the compost heap and the water butt at the far end of the plot rather than next to the back door. This sounds like self sabotage and it is the single best thing I have done for the amount of walking I do in a season. On a busy weekend it adds something close to two kilometres.
Alternate sides deliberately. Dig with your left foot forward for a stretch, then swap. Carry the barrow handles with a different grip. Nobody does this naturally and it takes about a week to become automatic.
Then stop before the last job. The injury almost always arrives in the final twenty minutes, when you decide to shift one more load because the light is going. Thirty bags of leaf mould taught me that the cost of leaving six of them until tomorrow is zero.
If you are starting a plot from nothing this year, the sequencing advice in my notes on starting a garden in a small space matters more than any of this, because an unplanned plot creates unnecessary carrying. And if garden work leaves you wired rather than tired at bedtime, that is a common pattern worth reading about in the piece on sleeping better naturally. More on the physical side of living well sits in the wellness section.
FAQ
Does gardening really count towards 150 minutes a week?
Yes for the energy expenditure, and the guidance is explicit about that. Count only the jobs at 3.5 METs or above, so weeding, raking, digging, mowing and barrow work. Watering and sowing do not reach the threshold, however long you spend on them.
How many calories does an hour of weeding burn?
For a 70 kilogram adult, roughly 245 kilocalories at 3.5 METs. That is an estimate with real error bars, because how hard you weed varies by a factor of two and no tracker on your wrist can see the difference.
Is gardening enough to keep me strong as I get older?
For grip, legs and general carrying capacity, a regular season of real garden work does a lot. It gives you almost nothing for upper body pushing or pulling strength. Two sets of press ups against a kitchen worktop twice a week fill that gap in about four minutes.
Should I warm up before heavy garden work?
Five minutes of ordinary walking around the plot and ten slow squats is plenty, and I would skip stretching entirely beforehand. The jobs worth preparing for are digging, barrow loads and anything overhead. Starting the afternoon with a heavy sack is where most strains come from.
More in Wellness
Wellness
Why Natural Deodorant Fails in the First Three Weeks
Around the third week of a switch, the messages start arriving.
Wellness
Dry Winter Skin and the Natural Fixes That Actually Help
By the second week of November my knuckles crack when I make a fist, my shins flake onto dark trousers, and the skin around my...
Wellness
How to Eat More Fiber Without Bloating or Discomfort
You know you should eat more fiber, but the last time you tried, you spent an afternoon bloated and regretting that giant bowl...