Forced Rhubarb Season and Whether the Premium Is Worth It
In the third week of January a 400 g punnet of pale pink rhubarb turned up in my local greengrocer at 3.20 pounds, next to thick green outdoor stems at 1.80 pounds a kilo that had clearly travelled a long way. Most people walked past both.

In the third week of January a 400 g punnet of pale pink rhubarb turned up in my local greengrocer at 3.20 pounds, next to thick green outdoor stems at 1.80 pounds a kilo that had clearly travelled a long way. Most people walked past both. The one person who asked me about the pink punnet assumed the colour meant the stems had been dyed.
Neither reaction is right, and the gap between them is worth roughly four pounds a month if you cook rhubarb at all. So here is when the forced season actually runs, what the growers are doing inside those sheds, what the premium genuinely buys you, and the two months of the year when the cheap stems are the smarter purchase.
What actually happens in a forcing shed
Forced rhubarb is not a variety. It is a growing method roughly two centuries old, concentrated in a patch of West Yorkshire between Wakefield, Morley and Rothwell that the trade calls the Rhubarb Triangle. Yorkshire forced rhubarb has carried protected designation of origin status since 2010, the same legal shelter given to Melton Mowbray pork pies and Jersey Royals.
The crowns spend two years outdoors doing nothing a gardener would call productive. They sit through two autumns and two winters collecting what growers call cold units, the accumulated hours below about 3 C that tell the root its dormancy requirement has been met. Around November the crowns are lifted out of the field, soil and all, and packed into long, unlit, gently heated sheds kept somewhere near 10 to 13 C.
In the dark there is no light to photosynthesise with, so the plant empties the starch it banked in the root into new growth instead. Stems come up fast, thin and pale, and the leaf at the top stays small, floppy and yellow, because a leaf is no use in a dark shed. Harvesting is done by candlelight, and that is not a visitor attraction. Even brief exposure to light flips the plant back toward making leaves, which turns the stem green and fibrous and ends its value within a day or two.
Each crown gets one forcing season and one only. After the harvest the root has spent everything it stored and is usually composted or dug back into the field. That single-use economics is most of the reason the stems cost what they cost.
Which rhubarb to buy, and when
There are effectively three rhubarb seasons in a northern European or northern US year, and they are not interchangeable in the kitchen. Treating them as one ingredient is how people end up disappointed in both directions.
| When | What is on the shelf | Rough price per kg | Best use |
|---|---|---|---|
| January to early March | Forced, pale pink, thin, small yellow leaf | 6 to 9 pounds | Roasting, fools, anything served in visible pieces |
| Mid March to April | First outdoor stems, pink at the base, green higher up | 3 to 5 pounds | Crumbles, cakes, poaching with orange |
| May to July | Maincrop outdoor, thick and mostly green | 1.50 to 3 pounds | Jam, chutney, cordial, freezing in bulk |
| August onward | Garden stems only, tough and low in acid | not usually sold | Leave the plant to rebuild the root |
Those prices are what I wrote down through 2026 at a mix of market stalls and supermarket shelves in the north of England. They swing a long way between a market town and a city centre, so read them as ratios rather than figures. The ratio is the stable part: forced costs about three times maincrop, almost every year.
If you already shop around seasonal vegetables in November, rhubarb is the thing that plugs the February gap, the weeks when stored roots have gone soft and winter citrus is carrying the fruit bowl on its own.
The premium buys texture, not sweetness
The line you hear in shops and read in most recipe introductions is that forced rhubarb is sweeter, so you use less sugar, so it pays for itself. That is the part I would push back on.
Forced stems are less sour, which is a different claim. In my kitchen the difference came out at about 25 g of sugar saved per 500 g of fruit, a few pence. Nobody recovers a five pound premium on sugar. What you pay for is structure. The stems are thin and evenly coloured through, so they hold a square edge when roasted and give a syrup that comes out genuinely scarlet. Maincrop stems in May collapse into khaki threads in a pink puddle. They taste fine. They look like something went wrong.
So the honest rule is about where the rhubarb will be seen. Pay for forced when the pieces stay visible: on top of a pavlova, next to yogurt, folded through a fool, spooned over porridge. Do not pay for it when it is destined to be boiled to a pulp. Jam made with January forced rhubarb at 7 pounds a kilo is an expensive way to produce something indistinguishable from jam made in May at 2 pounds. I did exactly that once, to settle the question, and the only lasting result was a note in the back of a notebook telling me not to do it again.
One other claim worth refusing is that shed-grown rhubarb is somehow less natural. The sheds are dark, pests are scarce in the dark, and spraying a crop cut within weeks of starting into growth makes little sense to anyone paying for the spray. Certified organic forced rhubarb is a separate question, and it is hard to find. I have come across it twice in four years, both times through a veg box.
Choosing stems and keeping them firm
Look for gloss and listen for a snap. A good stem breaks cleanly with a sound. If it bends into a curve and refuses to break, it has been out of the cold for several days and the water has gone. The cut end should look wet and slightly translucent, not dry and brown-ringed.
The leaf is the most reliable signal in January. On genuine forced stems it is small, limp and yellow-green. A firm, dark, properly formed leaf on a January stem means that stem has seen daylight, and the flesh underneath will be stringier than the price suggests. Trim the leaves off before the stems go anywhere near the fridge. They are high in oxalic acid, not edible in any quantity worth the risk, and perfectly good on the compost heap.
Wrap trimmed stems in a damp tea towel and keep them in the fridge drawer, loose rather than sealed in plastic, and they hold five to seven days. For the freezer, chop into 3 cm lengths, open freeze on a tray so the pieces stay separate, then bag. They keep about six months. Freezing destroys the structural advantage you paid the premium for, though, so the sensible plan is to freeze maincrop in June and eat forced fresh in February.
Cooking it so the shape survives
Roast, do not stew. Spread 500 g of 4 cm lengths in a single layer in a shallow dish, scatter over 2 tablespoons of sugar rather than the 4 most recipes ask for, add a tablespoon of orange juice, and put it in at 180 C fan with no foil and no stirring. Check at 12 minutes. By 15 or 16 the pieces should be soft through but still square at the corners, sitting in a thin crimson syrup. Past 20 minutes you have a very good compote and no shape at all.
What I have never managed to work out is why some batches finish scarlet and others finish a dull brownish pink from what looks like the same punnet and the same oven. My suspicion is pan material and acidity, and my sample size is too small to say so with any confidence.
A useful move this week: if forced rhubarb is in your shop now, buy 500 g, roast it plainly, keep the syrup for fizzy water, and judge the premium for yourself with the evidence in front of you. Then put a reminder in for May to buy three kilos of the cheap green stuff for jam. Everything else we have published on eating with the calendar sits in the seasonal section.
FAQ
When does forced rhubarb season start?
Harvesting begins in the last days of December in the earliest sheds, but the stems reach most shops in the second or third week of January and the supply is steady until the end of March. February is usually the easiest month to find it at a fair price.
Is forced rhubarb sweeter than outdoor rhubarb?
It is less sour rather than noticeably sweeter. The practical saving was around 25 g of sugar per 500 g of fruit, so sweetness is a poor reason to pay triple. Texture and colour are the real reasons.
Can I force rhubarb in my own garden?
Yes, on an established crown that is at least three years old. Put a bucket or a terracotta forcer over it in January, block out all light, and cut the pale stems about six weeks later. Force the same crown once every three years at most, and never two years running, or you will lose the plant.
Why is forced rhubarb harvested by candlelight?
Light tells the plant to start making leaves instead of stem. A shed lit with work lamps would produce green, tough, bitter stalks within a day or so, which is why growers still cut by candle in the dark.
More in Seasonal
Seasonal
Bare Root Planting Season and Why It Beats Potted Plants
A metre of mixed native hedge costs about 95 pence in January and about 9 pounds in June.
Seasonal
Brussels Sprouts Season and How to Cook Them Well
Most people who say they hate Brussels sprouts have only eaten them boiled grey, bitter and soft, usually in late December when...
Seasonal
Winter Citrus Season and How to Choose the Best Fruit
You buy a net of oranges in January, take them home, and half of them are dry, pithy and sour.