How to Make Organic Bone Broth at Home for Less
A 500 ml jar of organic bone broth costs 4 to 7 pounds in most shops, which makes a daily mug of it a luxury. The frustrating part is that the main ingredient is something most kitchens already throw away: the bones left over from a roast.

A 500 ml jar of organic bone broth costs 4 to 7 pounds in most shops, which makes a daily mug of it a luxury. The frustrating part is that the main ingredient is something most kitchens already throw away: the bones left over from a roast. Making organic bone broth at home turns that waste into four or five litres of rich, gelled stock for roughly the price of a few onions and a bag of carrots, and it asks very little of you beyond patience.
This guide covers which bones to use, how long to simmer them, why your broth may refuse to set, and how to store it so none of it goes to waste.
Why organic bone broth is worth making yourself
The case for homemade is mostly about money and control. A free range organic chicken already costs more than a conventional bird, so getting a second meal out of its carcass stretches that spend in a way that really adds up. Two roast chickens a month can give you around eight litres of broth, worth 60 to 100 pounds in jars.
Control matters too. Many shop broths add yeast extract, sugar or "natural flavourings" to make up for a short cooking time. When you make it yourself you choose the salt level, the vegetables and the herbs. If you are trying to work out where organic labels really count, our guide to which foods are actually worth buying organic is a useful companion, because animal products are one of the places where the standard makes a real difference to how the animal was raised.
Choosing bones for a broth that sets
The single biggest factor in a good broth is collagen, and collagen lives in joints, skin and cartilage rather than in clean marrow bones. A broth rich in collagen sets to a wobbly jelly in the fridge. That jelly is the sign you have done it right.
- Chicken carcass: one roast carcass plus wing tips gives a light, everyday broth. Add 2 or 3 chicken feet if your butcher sells them; they cost pennies and gel a pot on their own.
- Beef: ask for knuckle or oxtail mixed with a few marrow bones. Around 1.5 kg of mixed beef bones suits a 6 litre pot.
- Pork: trotters are the cheapest collagen there is. Half a trotter in a chicken broth makes it noticeably richer.
- Lamb: neck bones work well but taste strong, so save lamb broth for stews and soups rather than sipping.
Organic butchers often give bones away or sell them for 1 to 3 pounds a bag. Ask at the counter on a weekday morning, when they are trimming stock for the week.
A simple method for organic bone broth
This makes about 4 litres from one large chicken carcass or 1.5 kg of beef bones.
- Roast the bones. For beef or pork, roast at 220C for 30 to 40 minutes until well browned. This step gives a deeper colour and flavour. A chicken carcass from a roast is already cooked, so skip it.
- Fill the pot. Put the bones in a 6 litre pot and cover with about 4.5 litres of cold water. Starting cold draws out more protein and gives a clearer broth.
- Add a splash of vinegar. One tablespoon of cider vinegar is plenty. Leave it 20 minutes before heating.
- Bring it up slowly. Heat over medium until small bubbles break the surface, then skim off the grey foam for the first 15 minutes.
- Simmer gently. Turn the heat down so the surface barely trembles. Chicken needs 6 to 10 hours, beef 12 to 18.
- Add vegetables late. Put in a halved onion, 2 carrots, 2 celery sticks, a bay leaf and a few peppercorns for the final 2 hours only.
- Strain and cool fast. Strain through a fine sieve, then cool the pot in a sink of cold water before it goes into the fridge.
A slow cooker on low does the same job with less supervision. Fill it to about 2 cm below the rim and let it run overnight. A pressure cooker cuts chicken broth to 2 hours and beef to 3, with a very similar result.
What it costs per litre
| Item | Typical organic cost |
|---|---|
| Chicken carcass from a roast | Already paid for |
| Onion, 2 carrots, 2 celery sticks | About 1.50 pounds |
| Bay leaf, peppercorns, vinegar | About 0.20 pounds |
| Gas or electricity for 8 hours on low | About 0.80 to 1.20 pounds |
| Total for 4 litres | Roughly 3 pounds, under 1 pound a litre |
The longer simmer myth
A lot of online advice says bone broth must simmer for 24, 36 or even 48 hours to be "real". In a home kitchen, that usually makes it worse. After about 10 hours, chicken bones start to break down into a cloudy, slightly bitter liquid, and the vegetables turn muddy. You also spend a day and a half of energy keeping the pot warm.
Collagen extraction slows sharply after the first 8 to 12 hours. If your broth is not setting, the fix is almost always more joints and feet, or less water, not more time. A pot with too much water will never gel no matter how long it bubbles. Aim for bones covered by about 3 cm of water and no more.
A rolling boil does similar harm. It emulsifies the fat into the liquid and leaves the broth greasy and flat. Keep it at a lazy simmer.
Storing broth so none of it goes to waste
Once cool, the fat hardens into a cap that seals the surface. Fridge broth keeps for 4 to 5 days; after that, freeze it in dated bags and use within 6 months.
- Portion it small. Silicone muffin trays hold about 100 ml each. Freeze, pop out the pucks and bag them. You can grab two for a pan sauce or eight for a soup.
- Leave headroom in jars. If you freeze in glass, leave at least 3 cm at the top and use straight sided jars to stop cracking.
- Reduce it first. Simmering 4 litres down to 1.5 litres takes about an hour and saves a lot of freezer space. Add water back when you use it.
Keep the fat, too. Chicken fat from the top of the jar is excellent for roasting potatoes. For more on keeping food from spoiling in the first place, see how to store organic produce so it lasts longer.
Ways to use a litre of broth in a week
Broth only saves money if you actually use it. A litre goes further than you think:
- Cook rice or barley in it instead of water for a richer side dish.
- Use 200 ml to loosen a pan sauce after frying chicken thighs or mushrooms.
- Make a quick noodle soup with ginger, garlic, greens and a soft egg in 10 minutes.
- Sip a mug seasoned with a pinch of salt and a squeeze of lemon on a cold morning.
If you build a weekly routine around one roast and one pot of broth, the cost of eating organic drops noticeably. Our guide on eating more organic without spending a fortune shows how this fits into a wider weekly plan.
Frequently asked questions
Why didn't my bone broth turn to jelly?
Usually there was too much water for the amount of collagen, or the bones were mostly clean marrow bones with little cartilage. Add chicken feet, wings or a pork trotter next time and cover the bones by only about 3 cm. The broth is still perfectly good to cook with even if it stays liquid.
Can I reuse bones for a second batch of broth?
Yes, once. A second batch made from the same bones will be lighter and gel less, so it works best for cooking grains or as the base for a strongly flavoured soup. After two batches the bones have given almost everything they have, and they should go in the food waste bin.
Is homemade bone broth safe to leave simmering overnight?
It is safe on a slow cooker set to low, which is designed to run unattended. Leaving a gas hob on overnight is not a good idea for fire safety reasons. If you use the hob, simmer during the day and finish the next morning after cooling the pot in the fridge overnight.
More in Organic Food
Organic Food
Organic Frozen Vegetables and When They Beat Fresh
A 300 gram bag of organic spinach costs about 2.20 in the chiller cabinet here, and roughly a third of mine used to end up in...
Organic Food
How to Make Organic Oat Milk at Home for Pennies
A litre of organic oat milk costs between 1.30 and 1.90 in most supermarkets here, and the ingredients list usually runs to six...
Organic Food
How to Freeze Fresh Herbs So They Keep Their Flavor
You paid three pounds for a bunch of organic coriander, used a handful in one curry, and watched the rest turn to green slime...