Do Refill Shops Actually Save You Money on Staples
There is a refill shop eleven minutes from my front door, and for about four months I treated it as the obvious answer to everything.

There is a refill shop eleven minutes from my front door, and for about four months I treated it as the obvious answer to everything. I carried jars there on a Saturday, filled them with oats and rice and washing up liquid, and felt like I had solved a problem. Then I started keeping the receipts next to my supermarket ones, and the picture turned out to be far less flattering than the shop's chalkboard suggests.
Over nine months I logged 31 refill purchases against the own label organic equivalent at two supermarkets. Eleven were cheaper at the refill shop. Nine were roughly level. The other eleven cost me more, sometimes a lot more. That is not an argument against refill shops. It is an argument against assuming they are cheap because they look frugal.
How to compare a refill price honestly
Refill shops almost always price by weight, usually per 100g or per kilo, and that is where the comparison gets slippery. A supermarket sells you 500g of organic oats for a fixed price. A refill shop sells you whatever you decide to pour. If you fill a jar with 640g because that is what the jar holds, you have not bought the same thing, and the till total tells you nothing useful.
So I started writing the per 100g figure on my phone before I poured anything. It takes about four seconds and it changed what I bought. Here is what nine months of that looks like for the items I buy most.
| Item | Refill shop | Supermarket own label organic | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Porridge oats | £0.32 per 100g | £0.21 per 100g | Supermarket wins clearly |
| Brown rice | £0.29 per 100g | £0.26 per 100g | Close enough to ignore |
| Red lentils | £0.34 per 100g | £0.30 per 100g | Supermarket just ahead |
| Ground cumin | £1.10 per 100g | £4.60 per 100g | Refill wins by a wide margin |
| Bicarbonate of soda | £0.22 per 100g | £0.95 per 100g | Refill wins |
| Washing up liquid | £0.48 per 100ml | £0.73 per 100ml | Refill wins |
| Laundry liquid | £0.41 per 100ml | £0.28 per 100ml | Supermarket wins |
The pattern is not random. Refill shops beat supermarkets on things that are cheap to produce but expensive to package in small amounts. They lose on high volume dry staples, because a supermarket buying oats by the pallet simply has better buying power than a shop buying them by the sack.
Where refills genuinely win
Spices are the clearest case and the one I would defend to anyone. A supermarket jar of organic cumin holds 38g and costs around £1.75. The same weight poured at my refill shop is about 42 pence. I have tested this with cumin, smoked paprika, turmeric, coriander seed and dried oregano, and the gap sits somewhere between three and five times every single visit.
Cleaning and household liquids come second, though less dramatically. The saving on washing up liquid works out to roughly £11 a year in my house, which is real but not life changing. What matters more is that I stopped buying a plastic bottle every five weeks.
Baking basics are the quiet third category. Bicarbonate of soda, citric acid, cream of tartar and food grade vinegar are all sold in small expensive tubs at supermarkets and in sacks at refill shops. If you clean with any of them, the saving is substantial.
Everything else, which is to say the bulk of a weekly shop, is where the chalkboard romance falls apart.
The advice I disagree with
The standard line is that buying loose is cheaper because you are not paying for packaging. I used to repeat it. It is mostly wrong, and the reason is boring: packaging is one of the smaller costs in a food item, while rent, staff, scale and wastage are large ones. A refill shop is a small independent retailer with high rent per square foot and a slow turnover on dry goods. Those costs land on your oats.
The second claim worth pushing back on is that refilling is automatically the greener choice. It usually is for liquids, where you are displacing a thick plastic bottle. For dry goods the maths is less obvious. The sacks the shop decants from are plastic too, and if you drive fifteen minutes each way for 800g of rice, the trip has already outweighed the packaging you avoided. I walk to mine. If I could not, I would refill liquids and spices only, and buy dry staples at the supermarket without any guilt about it.
If your goal is a lower grocery bill rather than a tidier bin, the leverage is almost entirely in volume and planning. Buying organic in bulk and the way you build a cheaper weekly food shop will both move your total more than any refill decision will.
The tare weight trap, and how to avoid it
Refill shops weigh your empty container first, write the figure on it, then subtract that from the full weight at the till. This is called taring, and it is where I have watched people quietly lose money.
The problem is heavy jars. A 1 litre Kilner jar weighs about 640g empty. If the shop's tare label smudges or the staff member types 540 instead of 640, you pay for 100g of oats you never received. I have had this happen twice that I noticed, which means it probably happened more times that I did not. Both times the shop refunded me without argument, but neither refund would have existed if I had not glanced at the scale.
Three habits fixed it for me. I use light containers, mostly old 500ml takeaway tubs and cotton bags, for anything priced under £1 per 100g. I keep the heavy glass jars at home and decant into them in the kitchen. And I watch the tare number go into the till rather than looking at my phone.
Making a first visit worth it
Go with a list of six items and nothing else. The instinct on a first visit is to fill every container you own, which is how people end up with 900g of quinoa and a vague sense of regret. My first trip cost £27 and about a third of it was waste.
Check the shop's price list before you pour. Most have a printed sheet by the door or prices chalked on the dispensers. Compare the per 100g figure against the supermarket price you already know, and walk past anything that is not clearly cheaper. On the spices, ignore the per 100g shock and work out what 30g costs, because 30g is a realistic amount of cumin to own.
Ask when the dry goods were last topped up. Flour, nuts and seeds in open gravity dispensers go stale faster than sealed packets, and a refill shop with slow turnover will sell you rancid walnuts at a good price. The two shops near me both answer this honestly. One restocks nuts weekly, the other every three weeks, and I buy nuts from exactly one of them.
My steady state after nine months is a short list: spices, bicarbonate of soda, citric acid, washing up liquid, oats only when they are on a discount, and nothing else. It saves me somewhere around £90 a year and removes maybe forty plastic containers from the house. That is a decent outcome. It is not the one the chalkboard promised.
Frequently asked questions
Are refill shops cheaper than supermarkets?
For spices, baking powders and cleaning liquids, usually yes, often by three times or more. For dry staples like oats, rice, pasta and flour, usually no, because supermarket buying power beats a small shop. Compare the price per 100g before you pour anything.
What containers should I take to a refill shop?
Light ones. Cotton bags, paper bags and old plastic tubs all work, and because they weigh almost nothing, a tare error costs you very little. Save the heavy glass jars for storing at home rather than carrying to the shop.
Is refilling better for the environment than packaging?
For liquids in thick plastic bottles, clearly yes. For dry goods it depends mostly on how you travel there. A walk or a cycle keeps the benefit. A fifteen minute drive for one kilo of rice cancels it out and then some.
How long do refilled dry goods keep?
Treat them as slightly older than a sealed packet, because they have sat in an open dispenser. I give refilled flour three months, nuts and seeds six weeks in the fridge, and whole spices a year. Label the jar with the date you filled it.
More in On a Budget
On a Budget
Eco Cleaning Sprays vs Homemade: The Cost Per Use
I kept a shoebox of cleaning receipts for seven months, mostly because I was annoyed.
On a Budget
How to Regrow Vegetables From Scraps and Save Money
Organic spring onions cost around $2.50 a bunch, and most of us throw the white roots in the bin without thinking twice.
On a Budget
How to Make Vegetable Stock From Kitchen Scraps for Free
A carton of organic vegetable stock costs around 1.80 pounds for a litre, and most of what goes into it is the stuff you peel...