How to Regrow Vegetables From Scraps and Save Money
Organic spring onions cost around $2.50 a bunch, and most of us throw the white roots in the bin without thinking twice.

Organic spring onions cost around $2.50 a bunch, and most of us throw the white roots in the bin without thinking twice. If you want to regrow vegetables from scraps, those roots are the easiest place to start, and they can keep handing you fresh green tops for weeks on a sunny windowsill.
I have been regrowing kitchen scraps for about six years, first in a rented flat with one south-facing window and now in a small garden. Some scraps are worth the effort and some are a waste of a jar. This guide covers which ones pay off, exactly how to set them up, and what you can realistically expect to save.
Which vegetables you can regrow from scraps
Not every scrap behaves the same way. It helps to sort them into three groups before you start filling jars.
Fast regrowers that pay off in days
- Spring onions and leeks. Keep 3 to 4 cm of the white base with roots attached. New green growth shows within 3 days and is ready to snip in 7 to 10.
- Lemongrass. Stand stalks with the base intact in water. Roots appear in about 2 weeks, then pot them up.
- Celery. Cut the base 5 cm from the bottom. Fresh leaves sprout from the centre within a week.
- Romaine and cos lettuce. A 5 cm stump in shallow water gives you a small handful of tender leaves after about 10 days.
Slower scraps that need soil
- Garlic cloves. A sprouting clove pushed 2 cm into a pot gives garlic greens in 2 weeks. A full bulb needs planting outside in autumn and takes 8 months.
- Potatoes. A chunk with two eyes, dried for a day, then planted 10 cm deep, will produce new potatoes in 10 to 12 weeks.
- Ginger. A plump piece with visible buds, laid flat in compost, sprouts in 3 to 4 weeks and gives a small harvest after 8 to 10 months.
Scraps that rarely earn their space
Carrot tops will grow pretty feathery leaves, but they will never grow a new carrot. Avocado stones take years to become a tree and almost never fruit indoors. They are fun projects with children, not a way to save money.
How to regrow spring onions, celery and lettuce in water
Water regrowing is where most people start, and it is where most people give up, usually because the jar turns slimy by day four. The method below avoids that.
- Cut the scrap cleanly with a sharp knife. Ragged ends rot faster.
- Use a narrow glass or jar so the scrap stands upright and only the bottom 1 to 2 cm sits in water. Submerging the whole base invites rot.
- Place it on the brightest windowsill you have. Six hours of light is ideal. In winter, a north window will still work for spring onions but not much else.
- Change the water every day, or every two days at most. This is the step people skip, and it is the one that matters.
- Snip greens with scissors once they reach 10 to 15 cm, leaving at least 3 cm behind so the plant can keep going.
Spring onions in water usually give two or three good cuttings before the growth turns thin and pale. At that point, move them into a pot of compost and they will keep producing for months.
Moving scraps into soil for a longer harvest
Water is only a nursery. A scrap has a limited store of energy, and once that runs out it needs nutrients from soil. Any peat-free multipurpose compost works. A 15 cm pot is enough for a cluster of five spring onion bases or one celery heart.
Plant the base so the roots are buried and the cut top sits just above the surface. Water until it drains from the bottom, then let the top 2 cm of compost dry out before watering again. Feed every two weeks with a diluted organic liquid feed, or with the water you used to soak a handful of banana peels for 48 hours if you prefer a free option.
If you have outdoor space, potatoes and garlic do far better in a bed or a 40 litre grow bag than in a small pot. Before you plant anything in the ground, it is worth spending ten minutes to test your garden soil at home so you know whether it needs compost or lime first.
How much money you really save
Here is an honest estimate based on my own kitchen over one year, using typical organic supermarket prices.
| Scrap | Typical organic price | Extra harvest from scraps | Rough yearly saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spring onions | $2.50 a bunch | About 2 bunches a month | $50 to $60 |
| Celery leaves and small stalks | $3.00 a head | Leaves for stock and salads | $15 to $20 |
| Garlic greens | $1.50 a bulb | Replaces chives in cooking | $10 to $15 |
| Potatoes from sprouted chunks | $2.00 a kilo | 3 to 4 kilos per grow bag | $8 to $12 |
That adds up to roughly $80 to $100 a year for very little effort. It will not replace your weekly shop, but spring onions alone more than pay for the compost. Pair it with a plan to build a cheaper weekly food shop and the small savings start to stack.
The common advice I disagree with
You will see endless posts claiming you can "never buy celery again" or "grow an endless supply of lettuce" from a single stump. That is not true, and believing it leads to disappointment.
A regrown celery base gives you leaves and a few thin stalks, not a full, crunchy head. A lettuce stump gives you one small salad's worth of leaves, then bolts. These plants are regrowing from stored energy, not starting fresh, so the second crop is always weaker than the first.
My view is simple. Regrow scraps for the parts that are expensive per gram and used in small amounts, like spring onion greens, garlic shoots and celery leaves. Do not expect regrowing to replace whole vegetables. For the main bulk of your vegetables, buying seasonally or buying organic in bulk will save far more than any windowsill experiment.
Troubleshooting slimy, rotten or leggy scraps
- Slimy base after three days. Too much water or not enough changes. Lower the level to 1 cm and refresh daily.
- Bad smell. Bacteria have taken hold. Trim off the soft part, rinse the jar with hot water and start again.
- Thin, pale, floppy growth. Not enough light. Move it closer to the glass or plant it in soil.
- Fungus gnats in the pot. The compost is staying too wet. Let the surface dry out and water from below.
- Potato chunks rotting in the ground. They were planted wet. Leave cut pieces on a plate for 24 hours to form a dry skin first.
One last tip: start with organic produce where you can. Some conventional potatoes and onions are treated to slow sprouting, which can make them reluctant to regrow at all.
Frequently asked questions
What vegetables can you regrow from scraps in water?
Spring onions, leeks, celery, romaine lettuce, lemongrass and bok choy all regrow well in a shallow jar of water. Spring onions are the most reliable and give a harvest in about a week. Everything else does better once moved into soil after roots form.
How many times can you regrow green onions?
In water, you can usually cut green onions two or three times before the growth turns thin. Planted in compost and fed every couple of weeks, the same bases can keep producing for three to six months. Replace them once the new shoots become weaker than a pencil.
Is it safe to eat vegetables regrown from scraps?
Yes, as long as the water is changed often and you discard anything slimy or foul smelling. Wash the greens as you would any fresh produce. If a scrap has visible mould, compost it rather than trying to rescue it.
More in On a Budget
On a Budget
Eco Cleaning Sprays vs Homemade: The Cost Per Use
I kept a shoebox of cleaning receipts for seven months, mostly because I was annoyed.
On a Budget
Do Refill Shops Actually Save You Money on Staples
There is a refill shop eleven minutes from my front door, and for about four months I treated it as the obvious answer to...
On a Budget
How to Make Vegetable Stock From Kitchen Scraps for Free
A carton of organic vegetable stock costs around 1.80 pounds for a litre, and most of what goes into it is the stuff you peel...